Reparations for slavery would not solve America’s problem with race relations

EDITOR’S NOTE: The Shinbone Star is happy to add Denise Shabazz to our staff. This is her debut article.

By DENISE SHABAZZ

When I was an erstwhile 19-year-old student at Howard University, I was all for reparations to make amends for slavery.

Howard University, a historically black institution, renewed my sense of pride and identity in being a young black woman who had been raised in a predominantly white neighborhood. I was captivated by the numerous protests on my campus calling for reparations, the end of apartheid in South Africa, and practically any issue that disenfranchised black people.

But now, more than 30 years later, I have no interest in reparations. Instead, I want more discussions on equality, more job opportunities, more justice in a dysfunctional legal system that’s stacked against black and brown people. Reparations are simply bandages that temporarily allay the historical scabs that haven’t healed. 

That’s not to say I’m not alarmed by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell’s tone-deaf response to the reparations debate, dismissing it because hundreds of years of racism were quelled by the election of America’s first African-American president, Barack Obama. Such an argument ignores the aftermath of Obama’s tenure.

Race relations have soured and people of color have been targeted at alarming rates under Donald Trump’s presidency.  Consequently, Obama’s presidency came with the proverbial “double-edged sword.”

With this reality, I know reparations won’t restore race relations; it would make things worse. I can only imagine the discussions from backwoods-minded ignoramuses who hated Obama. Imagine their talk about awarding money to black people for slavery! If anything, it would bolster their false belief that the payments are an affirmative action remedy that absolves all past racist inequities. 

Indeed, reparations are nothing new. 

A June 19 New York Times article details the impact of reparations for Japanese-Americans, Native Americans and African-Americans. Adeel Hassan and Jack Healey wrote that in 1948, Japanese-Americans were awarded “$37 million to 26,000 claimants, but no provision was made for the loss of freedom or the violation of human rights.” Forty years later, in 1988, Congress voted to “extend an apology and pay $20,000 to each Japanese-American survivor of the internment. More than $1.6 billion was paid to 82,219 eligible claimants.”

The article noted that the suffering the internees endured “could never be fully compensated.”

What makes it more difficult, too, for African-Americans is the mixed-race nature of our people. Many black people come from all parts of the diaspora, including Cuba, Haiti, the Dominican Republic, Brazil and Puerto Rico. How can the government even determine whose “black” lineage deserves compensation and for how much? I too was mildly amused to learn that I have Irish ancestry through one of those DNA ancestry kits.

No, the government can save its money. If anything, I’m elated that the issue has opened discussion on race relations. Hopefully, it can pave the way for authentic atonement: equality through jobs, education and the justice system.

12 thoughts on “Reparations for slavery would not solve America’s problem with race relations

  1. Welcome to the Star! Excellent piece and I agree 100%. In Canada our indigenous people have been suffering with the consequences of reparations for decades. No real solution in sight. Just more anger and misinformation that bleeds racism.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. WE AREN’T ASKING FOR NICETIES BETWEEN THE RACES. THAT WAS DAMAGED WHEN YOU’RE ANCESTORS STOLE MY ANCESTORS. WE GOT IT. AND WE DON’T NEED NO MORE FRIENDS FROM PEOPLE THAT HATE US FOR NO UNKNOWN REASON, AND THEY BROUGHT US HERE. IT WASN’T A CRUISE.SOME OF MY PEOPLE CHOSE DEATH OVER CAPTIVITY. NOW YOU TELL ME, IF WE WERE SO USED TO BEING USED, ABUSED, AND KILLED. WHY HAVE WE BEEN FIGHTING SINCE DAY ONE. GOD IS COMING FOR ALL THAT HAVE DONE THE “EYE FOR AN EYE”, WHEN YOU WERE STEALING AND KILLING FROM DAY ONE. I’VE GOT AN INTERESTING WORD FOR ALL THAT’S HAPPENING, AND GOING TO KEEP HAPPENING, “KARMA”!!!! THERE WILL NEVER BE A RESOLVE UNTIL THAT WHICH IS OWED FROM THIS COUNTRY, IS PAID. NOT WITH PAPER MONEY SO YOU CAN ELIMINATE THAT, BY GIVING US CRYPT O CURRENCY. BUT AS LONG AS THIS LIE IS BEING PRESENTED THAT WE’RE NO GOOD, AND THAT WE’RE LAZY, AND JUST GOOD FOR NOTHING, ALL OF THAT, IT’S OKAY, STICKS AND STONES PEOPLE. “THAT WHICH DOES NOT KILL US, MAKES US STRONGER, NOT WEALTHIER, BUT VERY STRONG. DO YOU FEEL THE GROUND RUMBLING UNDER YOUR FEET? THAT’S A BLACK MAN LOLOLOL!!!!! JESUS!!! #TRUTHBLAQQUSUGA #UNTILYOUDORIGHTBYME
      #EVERYTHINGYOUDOISGOINGTOFAIL
      #NOREPARATIONSNOVOTE2020
      #WRITEREPARATIONSINTOLAWNOW2020
      #SOSAIDTHEANCESTORS

      Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s